Whiskies Similar to Halcyon Caol Ila 17 Year Old?

This might be a bold statement, but for you—the whisky drinker—and the $150 a bottle this costs, it stands head and shoulders above most other offerings at the same price point. The balance of tropical fruit, smoke, and savory notes is exceptional. That kind of harmony simply isn’t found in the new Octomore releases or whatever over-the-top Ardbeg edition is currently making the rounds. Of everything released this year, you’d be hard-pressed to find anything else so rare, fun, flavorful, interesting, and classic—all at once. It’s an absolute must-have for any Islay fan.

Should You Buy It?

As you’ve likely gathered from the above: yes, you absolutely should. Caol Ila was once easy to find in independent bottlings—affordable and consistently respected among whisky lovers, and it still holds that reputation. However, even those once-cheap Caol Ilas are climbing in price, and the overall quality of what’s available hasn’t quite kept pace (we hate to sound like purists, but it’s a trend in many corners of the whisky world). If you’re seeking a definitive, unmistakable, and brilliantly crafted cask-strength Islay whisky—this is it.

Final Thoughts on the Halcyon Caol Ila 17 Year Old

In case it’s not clear already: yes, we’re fans. This is a stunning whisky to nose, let alone sip—offering a long, salty, tropical fruit finish that takes you right back to what classic Caol Ila used to be. Compared with the standard 18-year-old release, this is in another league. It costs more, yes—but it’s worth every extra penny.

Read the full article at Scotch Whisky Review: Halcyon Spirits Caol Ila 17 Year Old 2007