Johnnie Walker Black Label and Chivas Regal 12 are two of the best-known whiskies in the world, and you can usually find both for around $35. One leans smoky and structured, the other smooth and sweet. But which offers better value in the glass?
In this guide, we break down how each is made, how they taste, and where to buy them, so you can decide which $35 dram is right for you.
Johnnie Walker & Chivas Regal Brand Background
Johnnie Walker was founded in 19th-century Kilmarnock and built its reputation on consistency. Black Label became its flagship blend, known for its layered style and wide use of malt and grain whiskies.
Chivas Regal, originating in Aberdeen, built its blends around Speyside malts, especially from Strathisla. Chivas 12 leans into smoothness and subtle sweetness.
Same age statement, different philosophies: bold structure vs. gentle balance.
How They’re Made
Black Label blends over 30 whiskies from across Scotland, combining smoky Islay malts with robust Highland and Speyside components.
Chivas 12 focuses on a narrower profile, built around Speyside malt with a high malt-to-grain ratio for a mellow, rounded style.
Black Label is blended for structure and layered flavor; Chivas 12 is blended for smoothness and approachability.
Tasting Notes According To The Brands
Both brands provide clear guidance on what to expect in the glass.
Chivas Regal 12 is described by the distillery as “rich and generous,” with aromas of “wild herbs, heather, honey, and orchard fruits”. On the palate, it’s “round and creamy”, delivering flavors of “honey, vanilla, hazelnut, and butterscotch”, followed by a long, smooth finish.
Johnnie Walker Black Label promises a layered experience. The brand highlights “sweetness wrapped in smoke with a hint of pepper,” on the nose. The palate presents “sweet vanilla and creamy toffee” before finishing with “sweet fruit and smoky peat with mixed peels.”
Next, we’ll see how those tasting notes hold up under expert scrutiny.
What Do the Experts Say?
Expert reviews confirm what the brand tasting notes suggest, though each whisky appeals to different palates.
Chivas Regal 12 is praised for its smoothness and subtlety. Wine Enthusiast awarded it an impressive 93 points, calling it “light, mellow and mildly spiced”. According to the reviewer, Kara Newman, the whisky “feels soft and easy to enjoy.”
Johnnie Walker Black Label, by contrast, is often described as more complex. Wine Enthusiast gave it 87 points, describing it as “peaty and oily; by midpalate, the island/salty/baked bread influence of Talisker is undeniable.” The whisky “finishes with a kiss of dark caramel.”
Distiller gives it a high 84 rating, praising the integration of fruit, spice, and smoke. Interestingly, though, the reviewer here also notes that there is more to Black Label than meets the eye. Stephanie Moreno says, “The Black Label is definitely known as the peated Johnnie, but what people don’t discuss much are all the other goodies in the stocking.” Something to bear in mind.
Which Suits You Best?
If you prefer your whisky smooth, sweet, and easygoing, Chivas Regal 12 is likely the better fit. It leans into classic Speyside charm (light honey, soft fruits, and a creamy finish) with virtually no peat or smoke. It’s an ideal entry point for new whisky drinkers or those who prefer a gentler dram.
Johnnie Walker Black Label, by contrast, has more weight. The subtle smoke, dried fruit, and spice make it a bolder, more complex blend, as is noted by Stephanie Moreno. It suits drinkers who enjoy structure and depth, and it holds up well in cocktails like a Scotch Old Fashioned or a Highball.
In short:
Chivas 12 = mellow and sweet
JW Black = bold, smoky, and layered
Your ideal choice depends not on which is better, but on what you want from your glass.
Price & Where to Buy
In both the U.S. and U.K., these whiskies sit in the same bracket. Expect to pay around $35 for a 750ml bottle, or £25–£30 for 700ml. Prices vary slightly by retailer, but both are often discounted.
You’ll find them easily at major outlets like Total Wine, Drizly, Tesco, and Master of Malt. Availability is not an issue, they’re everywhere.
Johnnie Walker Black Label vs. Chivas Regal 12 Year Old: Which One Will You Choose?
Both whiskies deliver real value at $35, but they serve different tastes.
Chivas Regal 12 is smooth, sweet, and easy to drink. Johnnie Walker Black Label is richer, with layered spice and gentle smoke. One isn’t better than the other, it depends on your palate.
If you want a soft, Speyside-style dram, go with Chivas. If you’re after complexity and a touch of peat, pick Black Label.
Better still, try them side by side. You might find there’s room for both on your shelf.
Tried them both? Let us know which one wins for you every time.
Read the full article at Johnnie Walker Black vs. Chivas Regal 12: Which Whisky Wins at $35?
