Johnnie Walker Black Label is one of the best-known scotch whiskies in the world. Smooth, balanced, and great value, it has long been a benchmark blend.
Double Black, launched in 2011, promised a bolder twist with more smoke and sweetness. The question is simple. Is it worth the extra money, or does the classic still win on value?
What Makes Johnnie Walker Black Label a Classic?
Johnnie Walker Black Label is a 12-year-old blend made from around 40 malt and grain whiskies. It is aged for at least 12 years. Core malts include Cardhu, Blair Athol, and Caol Ila.
Tasting notes include honey, vanilla, dark fruit, and a soft wisp of peat. The smoke is there, but it never dominates.
It is also versatile, working well neat or in cocktails. That adaptability, along with its price point, has kept Black Label at the center of the Johnnie Walker range.
Johnnie Walker Double Black: A Smokier Take
Double Black was launched in 2011 as a bolder version of Black Label. Unlike the classic, it carries no age statement. This means younger whiskies are likely part of the blend.
The recipe contains a lot of Caol Ila, an Islay malt known for its smoky style. The result is more smoke, more sweetness, and a sharper edge.
On the nose, you get campfire smoke, charred wood, and vanilla. The palate shows toffee, fruit, and a hit of peat. The finish is drier and shorter than Black Label, with smoke and pepper left behind.
Phil Dwyer summed it up well: “Double Black is like Black Label’s louder, rowdier cousin. It amplifies the sweetness and the smoke, but it sacrifices complexity.”
What the Critics Say
Critical opinion on Double Black is mixed. Some reviewers enjoy the added peat and sweetness. Others feel it loses the balance that makes Black Label such a standout.
Phil noted, “The big difference is that Double Black doesn’t carry an age statement, so you’re getting younger, more aggressive spirit. It’s still good, but side-by-side with Black, it lacks that polish.”
On Thirty One Whiskey, the reviewer called Double Black “legitimately delicious” and even preferred it to Black Label. For them, the extra smoke and richness made the whisky more exciting.
Vin Perry-French has a balanced take on the two whiskies, saying: “While Double Black offers an intriguing smoky twist on a familiar friend, I still find myself reaching for the classic Black Label as my daily dram. That said, Double Black isn’t trying to replace its predecessor – it’s carving its own niche.”
The consensus is that Double Black is not a gimmick, but it is not an outright upgrade either.
Price and Value
In the UK, Black Label often sells for around £24 on offer, while Double Black is usually £35 to £40. In the U.S., Black averages $30 to $35, and Double Black about $40 to $45.
Phil put it plainly: “When Double Black is £40 and Black Label is on offer at £24, it’s hard to justify. But if you love peaty whisky and want something bold but affordable — it hits the mark.”
The Verdict
Johnnie Walker Black Label is still the benchmark. It is smooth, complex for the price, and widely respected as one of the best value scotch whiskies.
Johnnie Walker Double Black does what it sets out to do. It is smokier, sweeter, and more forceful.
The choice depends on your palate. If you want balance and refinement, stick with Black Label. If you want more smoke without stepping into the world of Islay single malts, Double Black is worth a try.
Read the full article at Johnnie Walker Double Black vs. Black Label: Is the Upgrade Worth It?
